Douglas' Reply to Lincoln at Ottawa.
September 3, 1858.
Mr. DOUGLAS — Fellow citizens: I will now occupy the half hour allotted me in replying to Mr. Lincoln. The first point to which I shall call your attention is, as to what I said about the organization of the Republican party in 1854, and the platform that was formed on the 5th of October of that year, and I will put the question to Mr. Lincoln whether or not he approves of each article in that platform ("he has answered already), and ask for a specific answer. ("He has answered." You cannot make him answer," &c.) I did not charge him with being a member of the committee which reported that platform ("Yes you did.") I charged that that platform was the platform of the Republican party adopted by them. The fact that it was the platform of the Republican party is not denied, but Mr. Lincoln now says, that although his name was on the committee which reported it, that he does not think he was there but thinks he was in Tazewell holding court. ("He said he was there.") Gentlemen, I ask you silence, and no interruption. Now, I want to remind Mr. Lincoln that he was at Springfield, when that convention was held and those resolutions were adopted. ("You can't do it." "He wasn't there," &c.)
[Mr. GLOVER, Chairman of the Republican Committee — I hope no Republican will interrupt Mr. Douglas. The masses listened to Mr. Lincoln attentively, and as respectable men we ought now to hear Mr. Douglas and without interruption.]
Mr. Douglas, resuming — The point I am going to remind Mr. Lincoln of is this: that after I had made my speech in 1854, during the fair, he gave me notice that he was going to reply to me next day. I was sick at the time, but I staid over in Springfield to hear his reply and to reply to him. On that day this very convention , the resolutions adopted by which I have read, was to meet in the Senate chamber. He spoke in the hall of the house; and when he got through his speech — my recollection is distinct, and I shall never forget it — Mr. Codding walked in as I took the stand to reply, and gave notice that the Republican State convention would meet instantly in the senate chamber, and called upon the Republicans to retire there and go into this very convention, instead of remaining and listening to me. (Three cheers for Douglas.)
Mr. LINCOLN, interrupting, excitedly and angrily — Judge, add that I went along with them (This interruption was made in a pitiful, mean, sneaking way, as Lincoln floundered around the stand.)
Mr. DOUGLAS — Gentlemen, Mr. Lincoln tells me to add that he went along with them to the Senate chamber. I will not add that, because I did not know whether he did or not.
Mr. Lincoln, again interrupting — I know he did not.
[Two of the Republican committee here seized Mr. Lincoln, and by a sudden jerk caused him to disappear from the front of the stand, one of them saying quite audibly, "What are you making such a fuss for. Douglas, didn't interrupt you, and can't you see that the people don't like it."
Mr. Douglas — I do not know whether he knows it or not, that is not the point, band I will yet bring him on to the question.
In the first place — Mr. Lincoln was selected by the very men who made the Republican organization, on that day to reply to me. He spoke for them and their party, and he was the leader of the party; and the very day he made his speech in reply to me preaching up this same doctrine of negro equality, under the Declaration of Independence, this Republican party met in Convention. — (Three cheers for Douglas.) Another evidence that he was acting in concert with them is to found in the fact that that convention waited an hour after its time of meeting to hear Lincoln's speech, and Codding, one of their leading men marched in the moment Lincoln got through, and gave notice that they did not want to hear me and would proceed with the business of the Convention. ("Strike him again," — three cheers, etc.) Still another fact. I have here a newspaper printed at Springfield, Mr. Lincoln's own town, in October 1854, a few days afterwards; publishing these resolutions, charging Mr. Lincoln with entertaining these sentiments, and trying to prove that they were also the sentiments of Mr. Yates, the candidate for Congress. This has been published on Mr. Lincoln over and over again, and never before has denied it. (Three cheers.)
But my friends, this denial of his that he did not act on this committee is a miserable quibble to avoid the main issue, (applause. "That's so,") which is that this Republican platform declares in favor of the unconditional repeal of the Fugitive Slave Law. Has Lincoln answered whether he endorsed that or not? (No, no.) I called his attention to it when I first addressed you and predicted that he would not answer. (Bravo, glorious and cheers.) How does he answer. Why, that he was not on the committee that wrote the resolutions. (Laughter.) I then repeated the next proposition contained in the resolutions which was to restrict slavery in those states in which it exists and asked him whether he endorsed it. Does he answer yes, or no? He said in reply, "I was not on the committee at the time; I was up in Tazwell." The next question I put to him was, whether he was in favor of prohibiting the admission of any more slave states into the Union. I put the question to him distinctly, whether, if the people of the territory, when they had a sufficient population to make a state, should form their constitution recognizing slavery, he would vote for or against its admission. ("That's it.") He is a candidate for the United States Senate, and it is possible, if he should be elected, that he should have to vote directly on that question. ("He never will.") I asked him to answer me and you whether he would vote to admit a state into the Union, with slavery or without it, as, its own people might choose. ("Hear him," "that's the doctrine," and applause.) — He did not answer that question. ("He never will.") He dodged that question, also, under the cover that he was not on the committee at the time, that he was not present when the platform was made. I want to know if he should happen to be in the senate when a state applied for admission, with a constitution acceptable to her own people, he would vote to admit that state if slavery was one of its institutions. (That's the question.) He avoids the answer.
Mr. Lincoln — interrupting the third time excitedly. No judge — (Mr. Lincoln again disappeared suddenly aided by a pull from behind.)
Mr. Douglas. It is true he gives the abolitionists to understand by a hint that he would not vote to admit such a State. And why? He goes on to say that the man who would talk about giving each State the right to have slavery, or not, as it pleased, was akin to the man who would muzzle the guns which thundered forth the annual joyous return of the day of our independence. (Great laughter.) He says that that kind of talk is casting a blight on the glory of this country. — What is the meaning of that? That he is no in favor of each state having the right to do as it pleases on the slavery question ("Stick it to him," "don't spare him," and applause.) I will put the question to him again and again, and I intend to force it out of him. (Immense applause.)
Then again, this platform which was made at Springfield by his own party, when he was its acknowledged head, provides that Republicans will insist on the abolition of slavery in the District of Columbia and I asked Lincoln specifically whether the agreed with then in that? Did you get an answer? ("No, no.") He is afraid to answer it. We will not vote for him.") He knows I will trot him down to Egypt. (Laughter and cheers.) I intend to make him answer there, (that's right,") or I will show the people of Illinois that he does not intend to answer these questions. ("Keep him to the point," "give us more," etc.) The convention to which I have been alluding goes a little further, and pledges itself to exclude slavery from all the territories over which the general government has exclusive jurisdiction north of 37 deg., 30 min., as well as South. Now I want to know whether he approves that provision. (He'll never answer and cheers.) I want him to answer, and when he does I want to know his opinion on another point, which is, whether he will redeem the pledge of this platform and resist the acquirement of any more territory unless slavery therein shall be forever prohibited. I want him to answer this last question. Each of the questions I have put to him are practical questions; questions based upon the fundamental principles of the Black republican party, and I want to know whether he is the first, last and only choice of a party with whom he does not agree in principle. (‘Great applause.’) (‘Rake him down.’) He does not deny but that that principle was unanimously adopted by the Republican party; he does not deny that the whole Republican party is pledged to it; he does not deny that a man who is not faithful to it is faithless to the Republican party, and now I want to know whether that party is unanimously in favor of a man who does not agree with them in their principles: I want to know whether the man who does not agree with them, and who is afraid to avow his differences and who dodges the issue, is the first, last and only choice of the republican party. (Cheers.) A voice, how about the conspiracy?
Mr. Douglas, never mind, I will come to that soon enough. (Bravo, Judge, hurra, three cheers for Douglas.) But the platform which I have read to you not only lays down these principles but it adds.
Resolved, That in furtherance of these principles we will use such constitutional and lawful means as shall seem best adapted to their accomplishment, and that we will support no man for office, under the general or state government, who is not positively and fully committed to the support of these principles, and whose personal character and conduct is not a guarantee that he is reliable, and who shall not have abjured old party allegiances and ties.
("Good," "you have him, &c.)
The Black Republican party stands pledged that they will never support Lincoln until he has pledged himself to that platform, (tremendous applause, men throwing up their hats and shouting "you've got him,") but he cannot devise his answer; he has not made up his mind whether he will or will not. (Great laughter.) He talked about everything else he could think of to occupy his hour and a half, and when he could not think of anything more to say, without an excuse for refusing to answer these questions, he sat down before his time was out. [Cheers.]
In relation to Mr. Lincoln's charge of conspiracy against me, I have one word to say. In his speech to-day he quotes a playful part of his speech at Springfield, about Stephen, and James, and Franklin, and Roger, and says that I did not take exception to it. I did not answer it, and he repeats it again. I did not take exception to this figure of his. He has a right to be as playful as he pleases in throwing his arguments together, and I will not object; but I did take objection to his second Springfield speech, in which he stated that he intended his first speech as a charge of corruption or conspiracy against the Supreme Court of the United States, President Pierce, President Buchanan, and myself. That gave the offensive character to the charge. He then said that when he made it he did not know whether it was true or not [laughter,] but inasmuch as Judge Douglas has not denied it, although he had replied to the other parts of his speech three times, he repeated it as a charge of conspiracy against me, thus charging me with moral turpitude. When he put it in that form I did say that inasmuch as he repeated the charge; simply because I did not deny it, I would deprive him of the opportunity of repeating it again by declaring that it was in all its bearing an infamous lie. [Three cheers for Douglas.] He says he will repeat it until I answer his folly, and nonsense about Stephen, and Franklin, and Rodger, and Bob, and James.
He studied that out, prepared that one sentence with the greatest care, committed it to memory, and put it in his first Springfield speech, and now he carries that speech around and reads that sentience to show how pretty it is. (Laughter.) His vanity is wounded because I will not go into that beautiful figure of his about the building of a house. (Renewed laughter.) All I have to say is, that I am not green enough to let him make a charge which he acknowledges he does not know to be true, and then take up my time in answering it, when I know it to be false and nobody else knows it to be true. (Cheers.)
I have not brought a charge of moral turpitude against him. When he, or any other man, brings one against me, instead of disproving it I will say that it is a lie, and let him prove it if he can. (Enthusiastic applause.)
I have lived twenty-five years in Illinois. I have served you with all the fidelity and ability which I possess, ("That's so," "good" and cheers,) and Mr. Lincoln is at liberty to attack my public action, my votes, and my conduct; but when he dares to attack my moral integrity, by a charge of conspiracy between myself, Chief Justice Taney, and the Supreme Court and two Presidents of the United States, I will repel it. — ("Three cheers for Douglas.")
Mr. Lincoln has not character enough for integrity and truth merely on his own ipse dixit to arraign President Buchanan, President Pierce, and nine judges of the Supreme Court not one of whom would be complimented by being put on an equality with him. ("Hit him again, three cheers," &c.) there is an unpardonable presumption in a man putting himself up before thousands of people, and pretending that his ipse dixit, without proof, without fact and without truth, is enough to bring down and destroy the purest and best of living men. ("Hear him. "Three cheers.")
Fellow0citizesn, my time is fast expiring; I must pass on. Mr. Lincoln wants to know why I voted against Mr. Chase's amendment to the Nebraska Bill. I will tell him. In the first place, the bill already conferred all the power which Congress had by giving the people the whole power over the subject. Chase offered a proviso that they might abolish slavery, which by implication would convey the idea that they could prohibit by not introducing that institution. Gen. Cass asked him to modify his amendment so as to provide that the people might either prohibit or introduce slavery, and thus make it fair and equal. Chase refused to so modify his proviso, and the Gen. Cass and all the rest of us voted it down. (Immense cheering.) Those facts appear on the journals and debates of Congress, where Mr. Lincoln found the charge, and if he had told the whole truth, there would have been no necessity for me to occupy your time in explaining the matter. (Laughter and applause.)
Mr. Lincoln wants t know why the world "state," as well as "territory" was put into the Nebraska Bill. I will tell him. It was put there to meet just such false arguments as he has been adducing. (Laughter.) That first, not only the people of the territories should do as they pleased, but that when they come to be admitted as States, they should come into the Union with or without slavery, as the people determine. I meant to knock in the head this Abolition doctrine of Mr. Lincoln's, that there shall be no more slave States, even, if the people want them. (Tremendous applause.) — And it does not do for him to say, or for any other Black Republican to say, that there is nobody in favor of the doctrine of no more slave States and that nobody wants to interfere with the right of the people to do as they please. What was the origin of the Missouri difficulty and the Missouri compromise? The people of Missouri formed a constitution as a slave state, and asked admission into the Union, but the Free Soil party of the North being in a majority, refused to admit her because she had slavery as one of her institutions. Hence this first slavery agitation arose upon a State and not upon a Territory, and yet Mr. Lincoln does not know why the word State was placed in the Kansas-Nebraska bill. — (Great laughter and applause.) The whole Abolition agitation arose on that doctrine of prohibiting a State from coming in with slavery or not, as it pleased, and that same doctrine is here in this Republican platform of 1854; it has never been repealed; and every Black Republican stands pledged by that platform never to vote for any man who is in favor of it. Yet Mr. Lincoln does not know that there is a man in the world who is in favor of preventing a Sate from coming in as it pleases, notwithstanding, the Springfield platform says that they, the Republican party, will no allow a State to come in under such circumstances. He is an ignorant man. (Cheers.)
Now you see that upon these very points, I am as far from bringing Mr. Lincoln upon the line as I ever was before. He does not want to avow his principles. I do want to avow mine, as clear as sunlight in mid-day. (Cheers and applause.) Democracy is founded upon the eternal principle of right. (That is talk.) The plainer these principles are avowed before the people, the stronger will be the support which they will receive. I only wish I had the power to make them so clear that they would shine in the heavens for every man, woman and child to read. (Loud cheering.) The first of those principles that I would like to proclaim would be in opposition to Mr. Lincoln's doctrine of uniformity between the different states, and I would declare instead the sovereign right of each State to decide the slavery question as well as all other domestic questions, for themselves, without interference from any other State or power whatsoever. (Hurrah for Douglas.)
When that principle is recognized you will have peace and harmony and fraternal feeling between all the States of the Union; until you do recognize that doctrine there will be sectional warfare agitating and disgracing the country. What does Mr. Lincoln propose? He says that the Union cannot exist divided into free and slave States. If it cannot endure this divided, then he must strive to make them all free or all slave, which will inevitably bring about a dissolution of the Union. (Cries of "he can't do it.")
Gentleman, I am told that my time is out, and I am obliged to stop. (Three times three cheers were here given for Senator Douglas.)
When Douglas had concluded the shouts were tremendous: his excoriation of Lincoln was so severe that the Republicans hung their heads in shame. The Democrats, however, were loud in their vociferation. About two-thirds of the meeting at once surrounded Douglas, and with music, cheers and every demonstration of enthusiastic admiration, they escorted him to his quarters at the hotel, where for several minutes they made the welkin ring with their cheers and applause.